Operabase Home

Past Production Reviews

15
Die Walküre, Wagner, Richard
D: Robert CarsenOliver Klöter
C: Pablo Heras-Casado
Die Walküre @ Teatro Real, Madrid 12 February 2020

'The Valkyries were superb.'

read more
www.musicomh.comKeith McDonnell
“The Valkyrie”: the human condition, according to Wagner

“The entire cast was cheered by the public, but Stuart Skelton in the role of Siegmund was the most acclaimed. Along with him, were René Pape (Hunding), Tomasz Konieczny (the god Wotan), Adrianne Pieczonka (Sieglinde), Ricarda Merbeth (Brünnilde), Daniela Sindram (Fricka), Julie Davies (Gerhilde), Samantha Crawford (Ortlinde) and Sandra Ferrández (Waltraute).”

read more
EL BOLETIN
Věc Makropulos, Janáček
D: Krzysztof Warlikowski
C: Susanna Mälkki
An intriguing affair: Janáček at the Paris Opéra de Bastille

German soprano Ricarda Merbeth, whose approach to the overwhelming role of Emilia Marty merits great recognition. A hugely demanding task, Merbeth surmounted this challenge to deliver a stunning performance, filled with seduction, power, frenetic emotion and, ultimately, redemption. However, the role of Emilia draws its power equally from the relationship with the story’s principal roles, Albert Gregor (tenor Kiss B. Atilla) and Jaroslav Prus (baritone Vincent Le Texier), two men both caught in the seductive snares of the bewitching Emilia. The relationship between these three was convincing to say the least, with Albert driven to a compelling emotional insanity by Emilia’s charms, and Jaroslav’s sorrow and heartbreak upon discovering the cost of his actions as the opera comes to its ultimate climax. In addition to such a compelling performance, there was no hint of a linguistic barrier from any of the singers. Unsurprisingly, a Czech opera requires a significantly greater amount of preparation with regards to the text and its pronunciation. With this in mind, German soprano Ricarda Merbeth (and many of the cast) took a year to fully prepare for the role, an effort that has quite clearly paid off, given the utterly persuasive rendition from all the singers involved. In the final moments of Janáček’s masterpiece, the audience is closed in by off-stage horns and a male choir, creating one final moment of sublime power as the story of Emilia Marty, and this epic production, is brought to its climactic finish.

read more
19 September 2013bachtrack.comLeopold Tobisch
Lear, Reimann
D: Calixto Bieito
C: Fabio Luisi
Lear

Bieito’s dark production was staged on an austere but effective set of wooden planks designed by Rebecca Ringst, which opened up for the storm scene. The production was acted with an intensity rarely seen on the opera stage and free of any Regietheater excesses. The division of Lear’s wealth was simply represented by the daughters grabbing their part of a loaf of bread. Goneril and Regan, the sisters from hell, were sung with devastating power by sopranos Ricarda Merbeth and Erika Sunnegårdh on May 23. Both nailed the high tessitura of their roles with exciting accuracy and penetration. The opera is “full on” for much of the evening; vocal climaxes succeed one another with harrowing regularity. The second half of the opera is more reflective, as Lear descends into madness and despair. At fifty-four, Skovhus looked and sounded as young and fit as his daughters. Innocence and reserve come less naturally to the composer’s language, but soprano Annette Dasch achieved glowing beauty as Cordelia. In an evening of remarkable performances, special mention must be made of countertenor Andrew Watts as Edgar, who sang in both chest and head register with outstanding power and stamina, and baritone Lauri Vasar as Gloucester, whose terrifying blinding was managed with consummate skill. This Lear was a big triumph for the entire team and the composer, who were greeted with enthusiasm far beyond the polite reception usually accorded late-twentieth-century works here.

read more
23 May 2016www.operanews.comStephen J. Mudge
Tristan und Isolde, Wagner, Richard
D: Claus GuthArturo Gama
C: Gianandrea Noseda
Tristan returns in triumph to the Teatro Regio

tage director Claus Guth focused on the passionate love story between the two, and highlighted its intimate facet by setting the action in a 19th century high-middle class apartment. Isolde wakes up in the morning in her bedroom to the nicely sung outside melody, and asks to see Tristan. The sets, designed by Christian Schmidt (who also took care of the costumes), featured a revolving structure that showed the elegantly furnished rooms of the apartment. In this way, the director was able to add some action to this otherwise quite static opera. Five hours has elapsed, and while part of the audience had left the house earlier, there were still enough spectators left to pay a big tribute of applause to all the cast members, who had accomplished the deed of bringing back Wagner’s masterpiece to Turin after a ten-year absence. And this was indeed deserved. For Maestro Gianandrea Noseda this was the first Tristan. The conductor prepared with great care for this debut, and worked out all the details with the orchestra of the Teatro Regio, which played with commitment and produced a compact, vibrant sound. The chorus, instructed by Claudio Fenoglio, contributed to the success of the performance.

read more
15 October 2017theoperacritic.comSilvia Luraghi
Elektra, Strauss
D: Harry Kupfer
C: Franz Welser-MöstAlexander Soddy
Das Opernglas

»Sein Hausdebüt an der Staatsoper gab Derek Welton als Orest und agierte mit sonorem, großen Bariton überzeugend.«

read more
01 October 2020T Rauchenwald
Opera Online

»Derek Welton hat die Rolle des Orest bereits in der gefeierten Elektra Aufführung bei den Salzburger Festspielen gesungen und zeigt auch hier wieder eine sehr gelungene Leistung, sicher und sehr präsent, wortverständlich und überzeugend.«

read more
23 September 2020www.opera-online.comHelmut Pitsch